Contents of this entry
The protected realm and its neighboursA jewel crosses the boundaryPrimary referencesRelated encyclopedia entries
The protected realm and its neighbours
Doriath’s security gives its people a different position from the exposed northern kingdoms of the Noldor. That difference does not put the realm outside history. Refugees, guests, diplomacy and prohibitions continually connect its internal life with events beyond the guarded borders.
Its relations with Dwarves include the craftsmanship associated with Menegroth and later the fatal dispute surrounding the Nauglamír. Its relations with Men include the fostering of Túrin and the confrontation with Beren. The histories cannot be reduced to a single permanent attitude towards either people.
A jewel crosses the boundary
Beren’s entry and Thingol’s demand draw Doriath into the quest for the Silmaril. The Girdle cannot prevent the consequences of desires cultivated within the kingdom. After Thingol’s death and Melian’s departure, the protection that has defined the realm no longer stands in the same way.
Dior’s attempt at renewal ends in the Second Kinslaying when Fëanor’s sons attack for the jewel. Elwing’s escape carries the remaining family history towards the Havens of Sirion, where the oath will cause further violence.
The name, often explained through the idea of a guarded or fenced land, should therefore be read as a historical condition rather than an assurance of permanent immunity. Christopher Tolkien’s discussions of the Doriath chapter also make it a useful case for distinguishing a coherent published presentation from the uneven state of the underlying late manuscripts.
Primary references
The Silmarillion, “Of the Sindar”, “Of Beren and Lúthien”, “Of Túrin Turambar” and “Of the Ruin of Doriath”; The War of the Jewels, commentary on the Doriath narrative.
